I'll go ahead and confess. We pay someone to do our lawn care. Over the years, we've canceled the service several times, resulting in feeble attempts to effectively carry out the mowing, pruning, fertilizing, raking and all else involved in keeping the yard maintained.
Why have we canceled? To save money? Not really. The money spent on lawn care is a value well worth the cost, in my opinion. To have a nicer looking yard? Partially. While I do a decent job with mowing, I've been known to kill more than one tree or bush in my lifetime from improper pruning and/or feeding.
The real reason I cancel the lawn service periodically? Because I tell myself I should be doing it myself. It's my job. Or at least it is the job of my teenage boys. Some of you are probably nodding your head in agreement. No doubt I could use the calorie burning associated with doing my own lawn care. And my teenagers definitely could use the productive activity.
However, my point is not to argue whether or not lawn care makes sense financially, or whether it is right or wrong, in and of itself, to have someone else take care of your yard. The thing that irritates me is that as long as I pay someone else to care for my yard, somewhere inside, at least subconsciously, I feel guilty because someone else is doing what I believe am supposed to be doing. I feel that I personally should be the one who mows the grass, prunes the bushes, etc.
But you know what is funny? I don't feel that way about vegetables. While I like gardening, I do not have an enormous sense of guilt whenever I buy produce at the grocery store, as if I should have planted, cultivated and harvested each of them myself. Sure, it would be a good experience. And taste good. And be a great family activity. And be economical. But I really am proud of myself when I put produce into my shopping cart instead of processed food, and I feel very little, if any, shame that I have not grown all of them myself.
And I do not feel guilty that I use an automatic washing machine to wash my clothes rather than cleaning them by hand, although I can see that hand washing would burn more calories than machine washing and would make me feel like I am working hard. But do I have any guilt when I throw my whites into a washing machine? Nope. Again, I'm literally proud that I am at least doing the laundry with my automatic machine.
Same for the dishes--absolutely no guilt over using an automatic dishwasher instead of doing them by hand. Or for utilizing the convenience of air conditioning, toasters, vacuum cleaners, and numberless other conveniences.
Although I was not alive at the time, I can guess that many of the conveniences that I take for granted and use without the slightest bit of guilt probably caused significant dilemmas for a number of people when they were first introduced. I can just hear the conversation: "Well, Joe may feel right about using that new flushing toilet in his home, but real men still use out houses."
It is interesting, though, that the list of which items are simply luxuries that only the most spoiled and lazy of us would consider using verses those that are a reasonable indulgence varies person to person. I am certain that there are many people who would not have a twinge of guilt over having someone else take care of their yard. But I do.
I also feel guilty when I use those floss pick devices that save time instead of using regular dental floss and doing it the "real" way. I really do (even though I continue to buy and use them). I tell myself that I ought to be disciplined enough to floss my teeth without having to pay the extra money for the easy-to-use floss devices.
And I feel guilty when someone else teaches my children piano lessons, because I know how to play the piano and am pretty sure I could teach it quite well. Forget for a moment whether or not my children would respond well to me teaching them piano. Either way, I feel guilty when I drop them off at someone else's house for piano lessons rather than teaching them myself.
I could make a rather lengthy list. One side would feature the things that I do for convenience that I feel guilty about and the other side would list the things that cause me little, if any guilt. I'll bet I could even rate each item to reflect how guilty (or not) I feel about each one.
But your list would be different.
Assume for a moment that money were not an issue (because otherwise it makes it too easy to argue that you should do everything the hard way, including picking up all the particles of dust off the carpet by hand rather than using a broom and dustpan (like my grandmother used to do) or a vacuum cleaner). What things would you still feel guilty about having something or someone else do for you, even if you could afford it? A Housekeeper? Personal chef? Robot that sweeps your floors? A grocery store that assembles and delivers your order to you rather than you shopping in person? Professional movers rather than lifting boxes yourself? Treadmill rather than running in the great outdoors?
Now, find a friend and try to defend each of the items you listed that you feel guilty about. Use your best arguments, like "my mother always did it that way", or "it is my role", or "why pay someone else when I can do it", or "I need to work harder".
How did you do? Were you convincing in your arguments?
Even when the tradeoff makes sense in terms of what it costs verses what you get, why do you still feel guilty (be sure to consider that both "cost" and "what you get" include things such as time and quality of life, not just money)?
For me, the cost of a vacuum cleaner and the cost to run and maintain it are more than offset by the time savings that allow me to do other things I need or want to do. Why don't I feel the same way about a lawn care service? The big realization is it is a construct of my mind, based on my life experiences, and has little, if anything, to do with the lawn care itself.
Could any of us benefit from considering some of the tradeoffs that may be tied to letting go a few of those "shoulds" or "musts" on our lists? Perhaps it would be worthwhile to re-examine the value of having more time to spend with our families, with friends, furthering our educations, reading a good book, or any of the many other things that so easily suffer in our world of over-scheduling and constant stimulation.